A New Memorial on the Mall

The National Mall in Washington, DC is chock-full of monuments of various sorts and various levels of architectural quality.

At the top of my list are the Lincoln Memorial, the Washington Monument and of course the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, all of which obtain greatness by expressing defined meanings and ideas through tangible, architectural means. At the bottom of my list, by far, is the relatively new (2004) World War II Memorial, which is a disgustingly exaggerated and filthily official example of knee-jerk historicism.

The National World War II Memorial is downright horrible. Photo courtesy Wikipedia.

Now a new memorial is joining the mix. Read on past the break to read about my opinions of the new Martin Luther King Jr. National Memorial.

The Martin Luther King Jr. National Memorial will be formally dedicated this Sunday. Check out this article about it in The New York Times (admittedly, it’s not a fantastic article, but it’s good enough).

The new Martin Luther King Jr. National Memorial

Now I haven’t been there, so all I’ve done is read news coverage of the memorial as well as a few criticisms, and seen the pictures. My first impressions? Not good. A pedantic, literal approach to a metaphor (In his famed I Have a Dream speech, King said, “With this faith we will be able to hew out of the mountain of despair a stone of hope”) is never a good method of design, and this memorial seems to be a case study in how to let a superficially simple understanding of complex issues and a key figure around whom they swirled take over a design. There may be some redeeming qualities, but there certainly don’t seem to be many in the pictures and descriptions that I’ve seen.

But hey, it could always be worse. It could occupy a spot directly between the Washington Monument and Lincoln Memorial, and it could use that prominent spot for a massive faux-classical civic plaza adorned with Roman arches and pillars, a large pool fully of flashy fountains and even some gold stars — because lots of gold stars probably symbolizes something and are so patriotic that they just can’t be a bad idea, right? So no, this new memorial is not nearly as bad as the truly horrible World War II one.

But that doesn’t mean I like it.


4 thoughts on “A New Memorial on the Mall

  1. […] even cancel the Sunday dedication of Washington’s new Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial, which I blogged about a few days ago. President Obama is scheduled to speak at that dedication. I wonder if he realizes that it’s […]

  2. […] It’s only fair to point out that Rothstein some of the exact same criticisms that I made here. Read on for the full […]

  3. […] people see it as ugly. And his disparaging of Washington’s newest memorials is deserved (see this post and this […]

  4. […] that contributes only to the worsening clutter on and around the Mall,” Will concludes. I agree about the worsening clutter, but that is the fault of appalling monuments to worshipful, middlebrow […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: